Showing posts with label Bush administration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bush administration. Show all posts

Saturday, July 11, 2009

The Art of Secrecy


During the first nine months of the Bush administration, nothing happened, because the new president had been elected to dismantle our confidence in the federal government. Remember he was vacationing, once again, when the ominous memo arrived warning Bush that Al Qaeda was planning to attack the country, and he was reading a book about a goat to school children when they did.

Suddenly the architect of do-nothing government and his evil mentor, Dick Cheney, panicked and abandoning the procedures and structures of constitutional government, in part to cover up their inaction (despite Richard Clarke, counter-terrorism aide in the White House and Bill Clinton's exit interview), came up with programs that attacked the very heart of American ideals: detention and torture of suspects both in the United States and abroad; extraordinary rendition, kidnapping foreign nationals to secret prisons where either contractors or "friendly" government agents beat, tortured, and often killed suspects; wiretapped American citizens who made telephone calls to Muslim countries to speak with family members, business associates, and friends; wiretapped attorneys and journalists, and perhaps members of Congress; and then denied it all.

The last gasp of American journalism, more likely because some real Americans with access to information leaked it to the New York Times and the Washington Post (as Daniel Ellsberg did with the Pentagon Papers), made us aware of these programs quite early in the Bush administration, early enough to have prevented Bush's re election. However, the scary tone frightened too many Americans into keeping with the guys who had failed to protect us in the first place and who were ransacking America in its aftermath.

This is more than incompetence. This was ideological warfare against the very traditions of American government and idealism, and it made money for the principals, too. Don't get me wrong: I've spent my career as an attorney and have no illusions about how government operates, no matter which party is in charge, and the egregious disregard for the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, along with the Geneva Conventions, during prior administrations. But this was different, very different, because there were attempts to justify their actions, just as the Nazi's did, with trumped up legal opinions, deceitful briefings to members of Congress, and the United Nations, and there is much more that we don't know. And they profited from their actions: Rumsfeld and Cheney got richer while in office.

The New York Times presents a story today about just how ineffective all of this wiretapping really was.

And talkingpointsmemo.com reports that the extent of the secret surveillance is still unknown and goes way beyond our wildest expectations. The Inspector General's report alludes to stuff that makes my civil libertarian heart quake.

This is why we need a full investigation and prosecutions, if appropriate, of Bush officials who intentionally refused to uphold the Constitution and laws of the United States. Remember that oath of office that Chief Justice Roberts blew during Obama's inauguration, well, it means something.

I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.

Monday, April 13, 2009

Mandatory Reading


As painful as it is to read these books, as citizens who desire a more humane and egalitarian world, we must know what has been done in our names. At least three books are mandatory: Philippe Sands "Torture Team"; Jane Mayer "The Dark Side"; and Naomi Klein "The Shock Doctrine."

Each points a finger at top members of the Bush Administration for taking the reigns of our government and turning our resources to defiling America, eroding a commitment to civil and human rights, devastating the efficacy of government, and all the while making exorbitant profits. The hundreds of thousands of lives destroyed by the Bush Administration during the course of its "war on terror" is horrifying in and of itself. However, the profits made by American corporations as the functions of government here and abroad were privatized add another dimension to the last eight years, especially when one sees just how much Donald Rumsfeld, Dick Cheney, and George Bush, Sr. made through the war in Iraq and the more pervasive "war on terror."

As informed citizens of this country and of the world, we must insist that the Obama Administration take the steps necessary to investigate, prosecute, and undo the damage done by the ideologues of the last presidency. We have no choice. This information is out there, and to choose not act is an act of such hubris and arrogance that I doubt the rest of the world will ever respect the United States again. No matter how popular Obama might seem today.

Sunday, January 11, 2009

More on Accountability


American law is built upon adoption of substantive principles as well as requirements of due process. This is the essence of the rule of law. We look to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights as well as laws and treaties for the substance of law: the right to free speech and assembly; freedom to believe in god or not; the right to vote in elections; the right to a trial by jury, etc. And before the government may take away life, liberty, property, or options, there must be due process: a series of steps that require notice, hearing, sometimes the right to counsel, confrontation of witnesses, and a deliberative process based upon rules of evidence.

This is not the exception, this is the rule of law.

So when I hear Attorney General Michael Mukasey defend the unlawful actions of the Bush administration as defensible good people, because each was acting to “protect the security in the country and in the belief that he or she was doing something lawful,” frankly I don't find this a legitimate reason not to use the American system of law to learn why and how these Bush officials, acting under oath to uphold and defend the constitution, instead subverted the constitution.

Motive although an important plot point on television trial dramas is not relevant in the real law.

Yesterday the New York Times published three opinion pieces on whether the Bush administration should be held accountable for the authorization and use of torture, wiretapping, and other unambiguous violations of the laws and treaties of the United States. Each of the authors--Charles Fried, former solicitor general of the US and current Harvard Law professor, Dalia Lithwick, senior editor at Slate, and Jack Balkin, Yale Law professor articulate different remedies for the abuses of the last eight years.

These essays are worth reading. Americans do need to weigh in on how important cleansing our international image is to the future of our country.

This week I attended a conference of law faculty, which was why I am in San Diego. I attended a discussion about holding not just Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Rice, Powell, and Gonzales accountable. At this one brown bag lunch, the conversation shifted to holding the lawyers who justified these illegal acts of torture, wiretapping, renditioning, often retroactively, accountable for willfully manipulating legal analysis to illegal ends, a real subversion of the rule of law. These lawyers include John Yoo, back as a tenured law professor at UC Berkeley, Jay Bybee, a judge on the federal appellate court, and David Addington, counsel to the Vice President.

One speaker, Jordan Paust, a current law professor at University of Houston Law School, former JAG lawyer, and therefore someone intimidately familiar with how military justice is supposed to work, and it's a rather esoteric arena, well, to listen to his earnest indignation about the perversion of the rule of law is quite convincing that truth and reconciliation hearings with promises of immunity just won't cut it.

It is somewhat comforting that unlike the Bush administration which dissolved the procedures of government in favor of the secret cabal, "President-elect Barack Obama is reported ready to fill one of the more obscure but powerful posts in his administration — the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs — with Cass Sunstein, a friend and former faculty colleague at the University of Chicago Law School." According to the Times, "Mr. Sunstein will be responsible for overseeing the Obama administration’s ambitious plans to overhaul a raft of regulatory principalities. His purview will range from financial services to workplace safety to environmental protection and consumer products. In effect, Mr. Sunstein will be reversing the office’s use in the Bush administration as a citdel of deregulation."

But moving forward isn't enough. In order to be a country devoted to the rule of law, we must enforce it. By letting Bush and Cheney and their lawyers escape accountability, we are doing nothing to reinstate the rule of law, just leaving a blank in the history of America post-911.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

What More Can Happen in the Next Two Weeks


Yes, I'm cynical about anything in the Middle East. I can still taste the suffering I witnessed during my visit to Jerusalem this summer when I stayed in East Jerusalem and wandered through the Old City.

It doesn't seem grotesquely cynical that the Israeli attack into Gaza occurred just weeks before the end of the Bush-Cheney "let's let the Jews be in charge of Jerusalem so that all of us Christians can rise to heaven" era, because Bush either encouraged it or did much more to sanction the barbarity of these last ten days.

No matter how insane the Middle East gets, the suffering of the men, women, and children of Gaza cannot be justified. They are being used as tools by Hamas and by the Israelis. And I fear a new generation of hatred is brewing.

This invasion isn't about ending missiles coming into settlements. Let's look at the legality of these settlements. This morning I heard this figure: the number of settlements in the West Bank and other captured territories has risen by 45% since Bush came into office.

Now just as the American press wasn't allowed to record the invasion of Iraq, the Israeli government has taken another tact from Bush-Cheney and clamped down on media coverage in Gaza.

However, news that Israeli strikes hit a UN school today, killing 30 Gazans was not suppressed.


Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, who is aiming to become the next prime minister of Israel, is certainly showing how tough and inhuman she is. What a way to make a name for yourself!

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told Haaretz on Tuesday that Israel has no interest in a prolonged offensive on the Gaza Strip, with 600 Palestinians dead already, the length of the siege and its ferocity are not necessarily linked.

A cease fire would not, as Livni claims, legitimize Hamas, which did, by the way, win an election.

A cease fire is the only ethical, humane, and responsible course of action.

Saturday, December 27, 2008

Bush's War on Women Continues


The Washington Post reported on December 26, 2008, that the CIA is handing out Viagra, yes, Viagra, to cooperative older Afghani chieftains in exchange for information about the Taliban. The little blue pill is now ten years old, and is being celebrated by becoming a tool in the "war on terror."

Having just finished reading "A Thousand Splendid Suns," the second novel by Khaled Hosseini, who also wrote "The Kite Runner," the use of Viagra is yet another notch in the belt of the Bush administration's war on women. Hosseini is an Afghani emigre to the United States, trained as a doctor, who brought to us in 2003 the wondrous novel "The Kite Runner," giving a face, flesh, and body to the turmoil in Afghanistan. In 2007, he published "A Thousand Splendid Suns," because he wanted to focus on the plight of women in tribal and Taliban Afghanistan.

Illiterate young women, many still girls, in tribal areas, are regularly wed to older men. That's bad enough. Now with access to Viagra, these practices take on such cruel and horrifying aspects that they should be added to the list of war crimes mounting against the Bush administration. It's rape, it's often a form of genocide.

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

It Really Is That Bad


As we count down the days until he leaves office and can't do any more harm, propublica.org has launched "Bush by the Numbers" to calculate just how bad it's been. It's interactive, so if you have additional statistics to add, with sourcing, of course, because this is propublica.org, now eligible for a Pulitzer Prize nomination, go to the site and submit your favorite Bush stats.

Start weeping!

The National Debt rose from $7.1 to $10.6 trillion in just eight years. Our children and grandchildren will be reeling from this mismanagement. Well, the entire world is reeling now.

As the unemployment rate rose, so did the percentage of Americans without health insurance. That figure rose from 14% to 15%.

High school graduation rates rose, that was surprising, due in part to the poor economy and to "No Child Left Behind," which did put pressure on poor performing schools. In 2000-2001, 71.7% of students graduated. Last year 74.4% did. One for W!

Two figures are extremely telling. First, the number immigrants deported from the US rose from 110,000 in 2001 to 350,000 in 2008.

And perhaps the most telling of this secretive and incompetent government is this figure: Freedom of Information requests increased from 2.2 million in 2000, the last year of the Clinton administration, to 21.8 million in 2007.

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Uncovering the Truth


Yesterday an old friend and I were speaking about just how long it might take to find out what really happened during the last eight years. For the first few months of the Bush presidency, if you recall, nothing happened, except for Dick Cheney creating a secret cabal of energy producers to come up with a tactic that would question the science of global warming, start the "drill, baby, drill" mentality as an answer to dependence on foreign oil, and develop a strategy for grabbing Iraqi oil fields. Oh, and Bush vacationed at the movie set that he calls "the ranch in Crawford."

Then 911 happened. The litany of what we know occurred seems like a list of nightmares: rendition, torture, invasion with ill-equipped troops and no plan for an occupation, roadside bombs, eavesdropping, segregating decision making into the Office of the Vice President and out of the State Department, fear, more fear, color coded days, anthrax, Katrina, etc.

When there were newspapers in the business of investigative reporting, we might have gotten more while it was happening. Now who is going to finance the Freedom of Information Act cases needed to get to the meat of the Bush administration's incompetency? (News is that CNN is going in the wire service business. Yet I was watching the crawl the other morning and CNN reported that "Ivan Watkins" not "Ivan Watson," an NPR reporter had his car bombed in Baghdad.) That's trustworthy reporting!

When ABC puts out a whitewashed interview with Bush and then claims it revealed something worthy, we know we cannot rely on the corporate press.

We will have to rely on scholars from universities that are beset by the same financial meltdown conditions that everyone else is suffering from. That is worrisome. Because we can't prevent this kind of misshapen government from happening again unless we know how it failed us. I don't mean a witch hunt. I care about restoration.

Monday, September 29, 2008

Accountability


The rule of law, the bedrock of American democracy, requires accountability. Yet in this fog of incompetence known as the Bush Administration, there has been none. Bush administration officials refuse to respond to Congressional subpoenas, refuse to testify, and just last week, finally, Cheney was ordered by a district court judge to preserve all of his documents, including the embarrassing ones about his energy cabal and his strategies with Congress. That case, of course, will be headed for the Supreme Court.

No accountability for the attacks on September 11, 2001, despite the 911 Commission and the Senate Report on pre-911 intelligence failures.

No accountability for the lies that led the United States to invade Iraq: even with the Senate Intelligence Committee Report, Part I and Part II.

No accountability for the failure to act when thousands of Americans were stranded during and through the long wake of Hurricane Katrina, a long wake that continues to this very day.

No accountability for approaching the telecommunications industry without warrants and without authority to set up elaborate spying networks of Americans and citizens of the world.

No accountability for the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel rationalizing the use of torture and making up phony legal analysis to rid this administration of the pesky rules of international war, the ones we wrote, called the Geneva Conventions, et al.

No accountability for the Justice Department's use of religious and political litmus tests, which decimated the professionalism of the Justice Department, including the Honors Program and the Voting Rights Section.

No accountability for the massive failure of the financial markets, every day losing millions of ordinary people's savings and retirement funds, pushing families into foreclosure and homelessness, and creating a world-wide financial crisis.

Today, finally, a little accountability. Mukasey has just announced that he is appointing a special prosecutor to look into the firings of the nine US attorneys, firings that were prompted solely because these professional men and women refused to take the Bush loyalty test.

The way America used to spread democracy was through our system of laws not through pre emptive attacks. Look around the world and see how many post-colonial constitutions are based on ours. Yet the impact of American aspirational law is dwindling. Fewer foreign courts rely on US Supreme Court analysis to justify their decisions.

These days, foreign courts in developed democracies often cite the rulings of the
European Court of Human Rights in cases concerning equality, liberty and prohibitions against cruel treatment, said Harold Hongju Koh, the dean of the Yale Law School. In those areas, Dean Koh said, “they tend not to look to the rulings of the U.S. Supreme Court.”

In the time it took for me to draft this post, the New York Stock market's Dow Jones Industrial Average just sunk over 100 points. Now another 10 while editing. Still going down after I updated the posting to reflect the appointment of a special prosecutor!


Thursday, September 18, 2008

Incompetence as a Strategy to Dismantle Government



It isn't just incompetence, although certainly the Bush administration is incompetent. This administration uses incompetence as a strategy for discrediting government. Dismantle government by appointing not the "best and the brightest" but the crony or the evangelical instead. Discredit government so that we can get rid of it.

Remember Michael Brown as the head of FEMA?

Remember Monica Goodling at the Department of Justice and her hiring based on religious beliefs and a degree from that bastion of excellence Regent University School of Law?

Last night I was speaking with a financial adviser who looked like she aged ten years in just the last few days. "I hope Paulson and the Federal Reserve know what they are doing," she confessed. She didn't exude confidence.

Looking at Sarah Palin, she appears to use the same strategy of governing: loyalty tests and cronism. It appears that she has appointed anyone to state office in Alaska who is still a friend from high school. Didn't Andrew Jackson try to end these practices when he created the civil service?

Yet since Bush took office many career professionals have evacuated the Department of Justice, State Department, Department of Education, Environmental Protection Agency, to name a few. The Voting Rights Section of the Justice Department used to be the place for the smartest young attorneys to post. Their responsibility was enforcement of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, probably the single most effective piece of federal civil rights legislation ever enacted. However, after two presidential elections where caging and voter ID requirements have succeeded in disenfranchising thousands of potential Democratic voters--mostly African American, poor, new voters, and older ones-- clearly the Voting Rights Section has gone the way of the rest of the Bush administration: cronism and incompetence.

It's all strategic, and that is the shame.

The US Commission on Civil Rights, one would believe from the name, would be dedicated to monitoring and confronting the historic discrimination against African Americans. Instead, the Bush administration manipulated the appointment process and stacked the Commission with right wing ideologues who oppose all methods of correcting racial inequity. The current Commission is obsessed with ending all forms of race conscious admissions to colleges and professional schools even though the US Supreme Court permits such considerations. Now the Commission has hired Hans von Spakovsky as a consultant to oversee the upcoming presidential elections although von Spakovsky was not confirmed as a member of the Federal Election Commission because of his radical beliefs.

It's all strategic, and that is the shame.